Lorac Pirates of the Caribbean Collection – Swatches and First Impression

I was so excited when I first saw this collection announced and decided to pick up some of it with my Ulta 20% off coupon. Lorac makes one of my favorite eyeshadow formulas and I usually jump on the opportunity to pick up their palettes. This collection was no exception. I couldn’t just stop at the eyeshadow palette, I also bought the cheek palette and one of the 6 lip duos.

Eyeshadow Palette | $52

Unfortunately, my mirror came broken in the top right corner, but that’s not that big of an ordeal. At first, I was a little disappointed with the shades but after seeing swatches and them up close they grew a little on me. Now that I have the palette in my hands, I’m a huge fan. Looking at them in the palette just doesn’t do them justice. You recieve 18 eyeshadows and a deluxe sized mini eye liner. This palette is a little chunky but includes a side compartment that the cheek palette fits right into. I think the packaging is gorgeous, although a little bulky.

These eyeshadows are all new shades in their PRO formula. If you have not tried this formula I highly recommend it. It’s beyond creamy and easy to work with. All the shades can be used wet or dry. As you can see below most of the shades are gorgeous but a couple of the mattes swatched a little choppy and stiff. These included Silent Mary, Bones, Tell No Tales, and Ghostly. I haven’t used these on my eyes yet, so I’m unsure if how they swatch translates to the eyes. The shade I’m most excited to use on the eyes is Black Pearl as it looks like a typical black gray shade but is really a duo-chrome purpley blue black shade. I’m also excited for the eye pencil, as I had a very hard time removing it from swatching it on my arm.

(L-R) First Row: Ghostly, Starry Night, Compass, Arrgh!, Black Pearl, Yo Ho, Bones, Silvermist, Treasure, Tell No Tales
Bottom Row: Shiver Me, Cursed, Matte-y, Lost at Sea, Pirates Chest, Sea Haze, Menace, Silent Mary, Black Eye Pencil


Cheek Palette | $30

I haven’t tried any of Loracs Color Source Blushes or Light Source Highlighters but have heard phenomenally things about them so was super excited to try them in this palette. These are all gorgeous and I can’t wait to try them out on the face. I was blown away by how creamy these felt when soft, they almost felt wet in a way. There are 4 shimmer shades and two mattes, three blushes and three highlights. The mattes are just as creamy as the highlights. The palette was a little smaller than I expected at first but I think that’s just because the packaging is a little slimmer, making it easy to put in the compartment on the eyeshadow collection. This would be a great palette to travel with.

(L-R) Top Row: Star Reader, Destined, Fortune
Bottom Row: Bold Spirit, Caribbean, Lost Soul

Lip Duo | $26

I also haven’t tried out any of Loracs lip products but I almost passed on these. They looked a little cheap but last minute I decided just to try it out. Unfortunately, I was right. Ultimately the packaging looks gorgeous but once fully opened the lipstick has clear looking plastic which just screams cheap to me. There are six colors to choose from. one being a bold teal but I stuck with a neutral pink in Me Hearties.

On one side of the lipgloss tube, there’s a small mirror which is a nice touch. To me, the lipgloss side seems perfect and then it’s almost like they gave up on the lipstick. These swatched okay, nothing out of this world. The lipstick pulls a little and takes a couple passes before it’s completely opaque. The lipgloss is pretty standard. It’s not super glossy and has zero shimmer in it. It seems like it may be a little sticky on the lips but I haven’t tried it out yet.

(L-R) Me Hearties Lipstick, Lipgloss

You may also like

1 Comment

Leave a Reply